| WG Resources - Books |
|
Ye Boundless Realms of Joy Forty West Gallery Psalms, Hymns and Anthems from the Isle of Man Francis Roads
Review by Paul Guiliunas: This publication, Research Report 11 from the Centre for Manx Studies of the University of Liverpool, is based on Francis's PhD thesis. It presents music from the Colby manuscripts, chosen because it is not found elsewhere. Most of it appears to have been composed on the Isle of Man, and does not occur in printed sources. A few pieces come from the standard West Gallery repertoire, but in variants that are peculiar to this collection. The principal motivation for publishing this music, stated both in Fenella Bazin's Foreword and in Francis's introduction, is to make available performing editions of material that would not otherwise be available. Francis indicates that it is directed at Manx choirs (and Manx texts have been provided as well as English in most cases), but that it is in a format suitable for the use of any choir. Along with the details relating to the Colby manuscripts the introduction gives some background to the West Gallery repertoire, clearly aimed at the general reader and I was interested in Francis's brief attempt to characterise the West Gallery style. However, I would have welcomed more discussion about West Gallery music in general, since Francis has some interesting points to make, but does not develop them. I was particularly struck by one statement: "there is no doubt that the two countries where the style was adopted with the greatest vigour were the USA and the Isle of Man". In addition to his general comments, Francis includes quite a lot of detail relating to the specific manuscripts, tunes and personalities that are the subject of his thesis. Obviously much of this has limited interest outside the Isle of Man, but it provides an excellent example of the kind of research that can, and should, be done on the corpus of manuscripts that still remain from the West Gallery period. It is worth buying just for that. The real reason for publication, of course, is to make the music available. It is well presented, with "Roadsian numbers" and other devices to aid performance. A keyboard reduction is provided, which purists can ignore if it offends them, although they should note that this merely mirrors early nineteenth century publishing practice. I fully support any attempt to make more West Gallery music available, and I would encourage all to buy this book. |